Scrutiny of returns under Section 61: ASMT-10, the reply, ASMT-12, and when a demand can follow
Section 61 lets the proper officer test a taxpayer's returns against the information available and ask for an explanation before anything is demanded. The procedure is short: ASMT-10, a reply in ASMT-11, then closure in ASMT-12 or action. The case law has settled two things and left one open. An accepted explanation closes the point, and a demand built on return discrepancies needs the ASMT-10 step first. Whether every demand must start with scrutiny is where the High Courts differ.
What Section 61 does
Section 61 is a desk check of the returns. The proper officer may scrutinise the return and related particulars "to verify the correctness of the return", tell the taxpayer of any discrepancy, and seek an explanation. It is not an audit (Section 65, which examines the books), not a search (Section 67), and it decides no demand by itself.
The section has three steps:
- Sub-section (1): the officer informs the taxpayer of the discrepancies noticed and seeks an explanation, in the manner prescribed, which is Rule 99.
- Sub-section (2): if the explanation is found acceptable, the taxpayer is informed and "no further action shall be taken in this regard".
- Sub-section (3): if no satisfactory explanation comes within thirty days or the further time allowed, or the taxpayer accepts the discrepancy but does not correct it, the officer may take action under Sections 65, 66 or 67, or proceed to determine tax under Section 73, 74 or, from 1 November 2024, Section 74A.
Section 74A was added to sub-section (3) by section 129 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024. It matters for scrutiny of FY 2024-25 onwards, because any demand for those years runs under Section 74A, not Sections 73 or 74 (see the limitation article).
The procedure, form by form
| Stage | Form | Time | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discrepancy communicated, with the amount quantified where possible | ASMT-10 | Officer sets the time for reply, not more than 30 days from service, or a further period he allows | Rule 99(1) |
| Taxpayer accepts and pays, or explains | ASMT-11 | Within the time in ASMT-10 | Rule 99(2) |
| Explanation or payment accepted, scrutiny closed | ASMT-12 | Within 30 days of the reply, under the CBIC SOP | Rule 99(3); Instruction 02/2023, para 6.1(v) |
| No reply, or reply not acceptable, or accepted but not corrected | Action under Sections 65, 66, 67, 73, 74 or 74A | Section 73/74 action within 15 days after the 30-day period if there is no reply, or within 30 days of an unacceptable reply, under the SOP | Section 61(3); Instruction 02/2023, para 6.1 |
Two points in Rule 99 are often missed. The notice is to quantify the tax, interest and other amounts "where possible", so a bare list of mismatches with no figures is weaker than the rule intends. And the reply can be an acceptance: the taxpayer may pay and say so in ASMT-11, which is the cheapest way out of a genuine error. Because a filed GSTR-3B cannot be revised, the payment is in practice made through Form DRC-03 and the reference given in the reply.
How CBIC runs it: the two SOPs
For Central Tax officers the procedure is set out in two instructions:
- Instruction No. 02/2022-GST dated 22.03.2022 for FY 2017-18 and 2018-19.
- Instruction No. 02/2023-GST dated 26.05.2023 for FY 2019-20 onwards, which moved scrutiny online.
Under the 2023 SOP:
- Selection. Returns are selected by the Directorate General of Analytics and Risk Management (DGARM). They appear on the proper officer's scrutiny dashboard in ACES-GST with the risk parameters and the likely revenue involved.
- Workload and schedule. Each proper officer scrutinises at least 4 GSTINs a month, covering all returns of the year for each. A month-wise schedule is approved by the Assistant or Deputy Commissioner.
- Notice. One compiled ASMT-10 may be issued for a financial year. The discrepancies "should, as far as possible, be specific in nature and not vague or general". Parameter-wise details and worksheets are attached, and the notice reaches the taxpayer through the common portal.
- Documents. Officers are asked to rely on the records already available and, as far as possible, not to call for documents before ASMT-10 is issued.
- Referral. A case may be referred to audit or anti-evasion with the approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.
State tax administrations issue their own instructions, and their procedure may differ in detail. No CBIC instruction replacing the 2023 SOP had been traced when this article was reviewed; check the CBIC website before relying on that.
Must a demand start with ASMT-10?
This is where the courts differ, and the answer depends on what the demand rests on.
Where scrutiny was in fact undertaken. The Madras High Court, in Mandarina Apartment Owners Welfare Association (16.07.2024), held that once returns are selected for scrutiny and discrepancies are found, issuing ASMT-10 under Rule 99 is mandatory. It set aside the orders and remanded the matters. The Gauhati High Court went further in PepsiCo India Holdings (19.09.2025). There a Section 73 notice for FY 2017-18 rested on a mismatch between GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C, and no ASMT-10 had been issued. The Court held that Section 73 was invoked without the procedure under Section 61, and quashed the notice.
Where the demand rests on independent material. The Allahabad High Court, in Neelkanth Entrepreneurs (Writ Tax No. 1024 of 2026), held that Section 61 is "not, as a matter of law, an invariable jurisdictional precondition" to a Section 74A notice. In its words, "Section 61 may lead to Section 74A but the reverse is not true." That notice arose from verification showing sub-contractors alleged to be fictitious, not from a mismatch in the taxpayer's own returns. The Court added that where the officer has only return-based discrepancy material, following Section 61 and Rule 99 may be a mandatory safeguard.
Read together, the decisions point the same way more than their headlines suggest:
- A demand that rests on what the returns themselves show is safest after ASMT-10 and a chance to explain.
- A demand that rests on outside material, such as an intelligence report, a supplier's cancellation or a search, need not pass through Section 61.
This is a reading of decisions from different High Courts, not a settled rule. A Supreme Court ruling squarely on the point would override it.
After the explanation is accepted
On this the decisions agree. In Goverdhandham Estate the department issued ASMT-10 on blocked credit for lifts and air-conditioners. It then issued a Section 73 notice while the reply was pending, and eight days later accepted the explanation in ASMT-12. The Rajasthan High Court quashed the Section 73 notice: "Once the explanation is accepted, no further proceedings could be drawn." The Revenue's special leave petition was reported dismissed by the Supreme Court on 14 October 2024. A dismissal at the leave stage does not by itself lay down law.
The Delhi High Court applied the same reading in Kemexel Ecommerce (31.10.2025). There a 2021 ASMT-10 for FY 2019-20 was closed in ASMT-12 in April 2023, and a Section 73 notice on the same grounds followed in May 2024. The Court held that "further action" in Section 61(2) includes a demand under Section 73. It also noted that Section 73 has no non-obstante clause, and quashed both the notice and the order.
Two limits are worth keeping in mind. These decisions concern the same discrepancy on the same grounds. They do not stop action on a different issue for the same year, or on fresh material that was not before the officer at scrutiny. And because the courts treat the ASMT-12 itself as the closure, it should be issued only after the reply has actually been examined.
Limitation does not wait for scrutiny
Scrutiny does not extend any time limit. The clock for a demand runs from the due date of the annual return:
- Section 73: the order is due within three years.
- Section 74: the order is due within five years.
- Section 74A (FY 2024-25 onwards): the notice is due within 42 months.
A scrutiny that is slow to reach its ASMT-10, or that sits on a reply, can leave too little time for a notice. The 2023 SOP itself asks officers to start action "well ahead of the time limits". In PepsiCo, as reported, fresh proceedings for FY 2017-18 were by then treated as barred by limitation, so the lapse could not be cured. The limitation calculator gives the dates for any year.
For the working paper
Officer:
- Issue ASMT-10 for discrepancies found on the returns before considering a demand on them. State each discrepancy specifically, quantify the tax and interest head by head where possible, and attach the working.
- Record the time allowed for reply and any extension granted, in writing.
- Decide the reply. If it is acceptable, issue ASMT-12 for the points accepted and say which points they are. A general "reply satisfactory" closes everything in the notice.
- If the reply is only partly acceptable, close the accepted points and carry forward only the rest. Do not issue a Section 73, 74 or 74A notice on points already accepted.
- Where action follows, the show cause notice should rest on the discrepancy and the reply, and say why the explanation was not accepted.
- Watch the limitation date from the start, not from the end of scrutiny.
Practitioner:
- Reply in ASMT-11 within the time, or ask for an extension before it runs out, in writing.
- Answer each point separately: accepted and paid (give the DRC-03 reference), explained with reconciliation, or disputed with reasons. Attach the reconciliation, not the whole ledger.
- Keep the ASMT-12. If a later notice repeats a point it closed, that is the first ground of challenge.
- If a demand arrives that rests only on return mismatches and no ASMT-10 was ever issued, raise the point in the reply to the notice itself, citing the decisions above for your jurisdiction.
Desktop tool: GST Pragyan Desktop's Return Scrutiny workspace prepares a reference draft of an ASMT-10, issue by issue, with the amount by tax head and the working behind it. It is a draft for the officer to verify against the record, not a notice ready to issue. See the Desktop Tool page.
Legal basis and links
Legal basis. Section 61, CGST Act, 2017, with sub-section (3) amended by section 129 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 to add Section 74A (in force from 01.11.2024, Notification No. 17/2024-Central Tax dated 27.09.2024); Rule 99, CGST Rules, 2017, and Forms GST ASMT-10, ASMT-11 and ASMT-12; Sections 65, 66, 67, 73, 74 and 74A; CBIC Instruction No. 02/2022-GST dated 22.03.2022 (FY 2017-18 and 2018-19) and Instruction No. 02/2023-GST dated 26.05.2023 (FY 2019-20 onwards); Goverdhandham Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, 2024:RJ-JP:2730-DB (Rajasthan High Court, Division Bench); Mandarina Apartment Owners Welfare Association v. Commercial Tax Officer, W.P. Nos. 15307 and 15330 of 2024 (Madras High Court, 16.07.2024); PepsiCo India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, WP(C) No. 6960 of 2023 (Gauhati High Court, 19.09.2025); Kemexel Ecommerce Pvt. Ltd. v. Sales Tax Officer, W.P.(C) 16555/2025 (Delhi High Court, 31.10.2025); Neelkanth Entrepreneurs Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P., Writ Tax No. 1024 of 2026 (Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench).
Common pitfall. Treating scrutiny as something that can be reopened. Once the explanation is accepted, Section 61(2) says no further action shall be taken in that regard, and the High Courts have quashed Section 73 notices issued afterwards on the same grounds. The second trap is the reverse: a demand built only on return mismatches, issued without ASMT-10 ever having been sent.

